Parliamentary Joint Committee Releases Report On Office of National Intelligence Bills
Tuesday 6 November 2018 @ 12.05 p.m. | Legal Research
The Office of National Intelligence Bill 2018 (CTH) (the ‘ONI Bill’) and the Office of National Intelligence (Consequential and Transitional Provisions) Bill 2018 (CTH) (the ‘Transitional Bill’) were introduced to the Commonwealth Parliament as a response to recommendations in the 2017 Independent Intelligence Review (the ‘Review’). Both the ONI Bill and Transitional Bill were referred to the Parliamentary Joint Committee on Intelligence and Security (the ‘Committee’) on 28 June 2018. The Advisory Report on the Office of National Intelligence Bill 2018 and the Office of National Intelligence (Consequential and Transitional Provisions) Bill 2018 (the ‘Report’) was tabled on 24 October 2018.
The 2017 Independent Intelligence Review
The Review was conducted by the Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet and was released on 18 July 2017. As summarised on the Department’s website:
“The Review examined the environment in which the intelligence community operates, and considered how effectively it serves Australia’s national interests. In particular the suitability of the current structural, legislative and oversight architecture of the intelligence community was considered.”
The Review made 23 general recommendations, including the establishment of the Office of National Intelligence (‘ONI’), which was to be an independent statutory agency that would report directly to the Prime Minister. ONI would also be the continuation of the Office of National Assessments (‘ONA’), which was established in February 1978 as a result of Australia’s first Royal Commission review into its intelligence and security agencies.
Bills
The ONI Bill was introduced on 28 June 2018 by the Attorney-General in the House of Representatives. As summarised in its explanatory statement:
“Specifically the Bill implements the recommendations of the Review in relation to ONI, including by the following:
- providing that ONI’s functions include to lead the national intelligence community (NIC) which will, for the purposes of the Bill, include the traditional AIC, the ACIC in its entirety, and the intelligence related activities and capabilities of the Department of Home Affairs, the AFP, AUSTRAC and the Department of Defence;
- providing that ONI’s assessment functions extend beyond ONA’s existing role to include matters of political, strategic or economic significance to Australia without an international aspect, to support the performance of any of their other functions or complement the work of the NIC;
- extending ONA’s existing evaluation role beyond foreign intelligence activities to include the intelligence activities and capabilities of the NIC;
- providing that ONI’s functions include providing advice to the Prime Minister on national intelligence priorities, requirements and capabilities and matters relating to the NIC more generally;
- providing ONI with a specific function of collecting, interpreting and disseminating information relating to matters of political, strategic or economic significance to Australia that is accessible to any section of the public;
- requiring ONI to perform its function of leading the NIC in ways that promote the appropriate integration of the intelligence capabilities of the NIC; and
- positioning the Director-General National Intelligence (Director-General) as the head of the NIC, whose responsibilities include keeping the Prime Minister informed on matters relating to the NIC.”
The Transitional Bill was introduced alongside the ONI Bill on 28 June 2018 by the Attorney-General. This Bill amends 19 different acts to assist in the proposed operation of the ONI Bill to establish ONI and will repeal the Office of National Assessments Act 1977 (CTH) which established ONA.
The Advisory Report
The Report says that the Committee looked at:
“the provisions of both bills, and how the proposed legislation reflects the recommendations from the Review. The Committee also examined whether ONI has been given adequate powers and functions to lead a better coordinated and more integrated intelligence community, and looked at any impact on the existing roles and statutory functions of the other Australian intelligence agencies.”
The Report listed 6 recommendations:
- “The Committee recommends that the Government request the Comprehensive Review into the Legal Framework of the National Intelligence Community to examine the consistency of the various provisions across national intelligence community legislation enabling these agencies to cooperate with foreign authorities.
- The Committee recommends that the Government amend clause 54(2) of the Office of National Intelligence Bill 2018 to ensure that the powers of the Director-General of National Intelligence under clause 13(2) cannot be delegated when approving an authority of another country as being capable of assisting ONI in the performance of its functions and the exercise of its powers.
- The Committee recommends the Office of National Intelligence Bill 2018 be amended to remove clause 43 (Offence—subsequent communications of certain information).
- The Committee recommends that clause 53 of the Office of National Intelligence Bill 2018 be amended to include a statutory requirement that the privacy rules be made public, except to the extent that those rules contain classified information.
- The Committee recommends that clause 53(4) of the Office of National Intelligence Bill 2018 be amended to require the Prime Minister to consult with the Privacy Commissioner, including by providing the Commissioner with a copy of the privacy rules the Prime Minister is proposing to make.
- The Committee recommends that, following the implementation of the recommendations in this report, the Office of National Intelligence Bill 2018 and the Office of National Intelligence (Consequential and Transitional Provisions) Bill 2018 be passed.”
The Committee concluded that in their view, the establishment of the ONI by the two bills would create a better co-ordinated and integrated National Intelligence Community, thus meeting the recommendations set out in the Review.
TimeBase is an independent, privately owned Australian legal publisher specialising in the online delivery of accurate, comprehensive and innovative legislation research tools including LawOne and unique Point-in-Time Products. Nothing on this website should be construed as legal advice and does not substitute for the advice of competent legal counsel.
Sources:
2017 Independent Intelligence Review (Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet
The Office of National Intelligence (Consequential and Transitional Provisions) Bill 2018 (CTH) and supporting materials available from Timebase's LawOne service.
The Office of National Intelligence Bill 2018 (CTH) and supporting materials available from Timebase's LawOne service.