Maggie Beer Products Acknowledges Labelling Likely To Be Misleading
Wednesday 20 August 2014 @ 10.17 a.m. | Trade & Commerce
The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) has accepted a court enforceable undertaking from Maggie Beer Products Pty Ltd (Maggie Beer Products) in which Maggie Beer Products acknowledges that its conduct was likely to have been misleading, in breach of the Australian Consumer Law (ACL).
Background
The undertaking relates to Maggie Beer Products’ place of origin representations on the labelling of “Maggie Beer” branded Ice cream (all flavours), Aged Red Wine Vinegar, Extra virgin olive oil and Rosemary and verjuice biscuits, representations made at a Local Fair held at a Woolworths Limited (Woolworths) supermarket in Mitcham, South Australia and representations made in correspondence sent by Maggie Beer Products to Woolworths.
“Maggie Beer” branded Ice cream, Extra virgin olive oil and Rosemary and verjuice biscuits are manufactured by third parties in Victoria, while “Maggie Beer” branded Aged Red Wine Vinegar is manufactured by a third party in Queensland.
However, since at least 2011, the following text and logo has been on the labelling of these products, in close proximity to each other:
- the “Maggie Beer” logo which depicts a pheasant with the words “Maggie Beer A Barossa Food Tradition”;
- the words “Made in Australia” or “Product of Australia”; and
- the words “Maggie Beer Products: 2 Keith Street Tanunda South Australia 5352”.
The ACCC considered that as a result of these representations in close proximity on the labels, a reasonable consumer would have gained the overall impression that each of these products was manufactured in Tanunda, the Barossa Valley and/or South Australia, when in fact this was not the case.
In addition, Maggie Beer Products made representations to the public during a “Local Fair” held at a Woolworths supermarket in Mitcham, South Australia in April 2013 that its Ice cream and Rosemary and verjuice biscuits were made in South Australia or were otherwise “local” products, when that was not the case.
Further, Maggie Beer Products made representations in correspondence with Woolworths that its Ice cream, Aged red wine vinegar, Extra virgin olive oil and Rosemary and verjuice biscuits were made in South Australia or were otherwise “local” products, when this was not the case.
Contraventions of the ACL
Maggie Beer Products has acknowledged that its product labelling, representations to the public at the “Local Fair” and representations to Woolworths were likely to have contravened ss 18 and 29(1)(k) of the ACL.
ACCC Chairman Rod Sims said:
“Consumers are often willing to pay premium prices for local products and businesses are following consumer demand by stocking local goods. Protecting the integrity of credence claims made about food products is a priority enforcement area for the ACCC … The Barossa Valley is a nationally recognised premium food and wine destination, and businesses in that region use place of origin claims to promote or distinguish their product from others in the market … Misleading representations about the origin of products to capitalise on this demand undermines the integrity of credence claims which are relied on by consumers and, equally important, can harm competing producers whose products are made locally.”
The ACCC Investigation
Maggie Beer Products has cooperated with the ACCC’s investigation and, as part of the undertaking, will amend its labelling so that the place of manufacture for products made outside of South Australia is made clear to consumers. It will also shortly publish an educative article in Food Magazine.
Beer said she was “shocked and horrified” by the claims and says she has never hidden where Maggie Beer Products are produced.
She commented:
“I want to unreservedly apologise to anyone who feels they have been misled I am horrified that anyone feels that way … I think the ACCC have a really important job to do, there is no way I ever felt there was anything we were doing wrong.”
Beer says she does not feel she has been unfairly targeted by the competition watchdog. This matter came to the ACCC’s attention independently of the recent ACCC investigation concerning Maggie Beer’s daughter Saskia Beer and her company Barossa Farm Produce (see ACCC MR 144/14). A copy of the undertaking is available on the ACCC’s public register.
TimeBase is an independent, privately owned Australian legal publisher specialising in the online delivery of accurate, comprehensive and innovative legislation research tools including LawOne and unique Point-in-Time Products.
Sources:
Article from smartcompany.com.au
Article from ACCC
